3) TRANSPARENCY IS AT THE HEART OF THE MAY 20 ELECTIONS IN VENEZUELA
By Nino Pagliccia
On May 20th Venezuelans will exert their right to elect their president and other local officials. It will be the fifth presidential election (and the 25th election of any type) to take place since 1999 when Hugo Chavez was elected president. Venezuelans take great pride in this fact, in a region that has seen far too many coups, military and otherwise.
However, there is a persistent campaign, endorsed by the US and Canadian governments, that this election will be a fraud. They will not give any proof for their assertion. On the other hand I decided to learn more about the Venezuelan electoral system, to see if such a deception is even possible. For that purpose I interviewed Wilfredo Perez Bianco, Consul General of the Bolivarian Republic of Venezuela in Vancouver, BC. What follows is my report from our conversation.
The first thing that Perez pointed out was that in order to understand the process that guarantees the right of Venezuelans to fairly elect their representatives, two articles of the constitution have to be kept in mind.
Article 62 of the Venezuelan constitution of 1999 establishes the democratic foundation of the electoral process. The first paragraph says, “All citizens have the right to participate freely in public affairs, directly or through their elected representatives.” And the last paragraph concludes, “It is the obligation of the State and the duty of society to facilitate the generation of the most favorable conditions for its practice.” It is significant that both State and society have a role in this process.
Article 63 in turn establishes, “Suffrage is a right. It is exercised through free, universal, direct and secret ballots. The law will guarantee the principle of individuality of suffrage and proportional representation.”
The Venezuelan Electoral Power bases all its actions on the 1999 constitution, the Organic Law of the Electoral Power, the Organic Law of the Electoral Processes and the Organic Law of the Civil Registry. According to the division of powers established in the constitution, it has functional and budgetary autonomy, which guarantees its independence from other State bodies.
“Its governing body is the National Electoral Council (CNE for its name in Spanish), responsible for the transparency of electoral and referendum processes that guarantee to all Venezuelans, the efficient organization of all electoral events that take place in the country,” stated Perez. “It is their responsibility to regulate, direct and supervise the activities of their subordinate bodies, as well as guarantee compliance with the constitutional principles attributed to the Electoral Power,” he continued.
Currently, the voting system in Venezuela is a fully automated process and can be audited in all its phases. In 2004, Venezuela became the first country in the world to hold a national election with machines that printed the voucher or receipt, and in 2012, the first elections were held with biometric authentication of the elector and the subsequent activation of the voting machine.
This technological platform allows the use of a conventional voting (electronic) ballot where the voters press the name, face or party affiliation of the candidate for the election office. This method of voting was further strengthened with the use of the Integral Authentication System (SAI), the last phase of automation, which allows the voter to activate the machine with their fingerprint. “This represents another guarantee for the integrity of the vote.”
Once the fingerprint is authenticated, the machine is activated so that the voter can vote directly on the screen or on the electronic ballot. The selected option appears on the screen and the voter has the possibility to confirm their vote by pressing the VOTE option.
This vote is stored randomly in the memory of the machine, and at the end of the day is recorded in the printed totaling records. Said votes are collated with the physical vouchers of the receipt box in the subsequent audit.
Perez emphasized, “The voting package of each machine travels encrypted through a secure network provided by the state telecommunications company CANTV. The network is isolated from the Internet and has multiple levels of security and authentication. No external computer can penetrate the election results.”
The totaling system rests on powerful servers, which receive the electoral results from all the voting machines in the country. The totaling system only receives data from voting machines authenticated and authorized by the CNE, which are protected with an encrypted alphanumeric key through an electronic signature. This key does not depend on any single party because it is shared between the CNE and all participating political organizations.
The Automated Voting System follows various phases of vote verification protocol: audit of the automated system itself; citizen verification; processes following the election in the presence of representatives of the parties.
The complete system of electoral guarantees also includes an international presence - International Electoral Accompaniment Program - to accompany and observe the electoral process, get to know the operation of the Venezuelan system, and even contribute to its improvement.
Perez clarified, “The participation allows electoral experts and other accredited persons, in all the technical and institutional stages, prior to the electoral event, during its development and after it. At all time, the accompanying persons interact with electoral authorities, technical teams of the CNE, electoral officials and with technical and political representatives of the participating political organizations, as well as with the media, within the framework of the conditions set by the CNE for the sovereignty and independence of Venezuela.”
In the May 20 elections, fifteen audits will be conducted in the different areas involved in the process of the Presidential Elections and Legislative Councils. These audits will comply with the standards used in the 2012 presidential election and the parliamentary elections of 2015 to guarantee transparency in the exercise of the vote.
The audits will be carried out in the presence of witnesses of political organizations, national observers, international accompaniers, and technicians from different accompaniment missions. Perez informed me that “these activities of revision can be followed in live broadcasts by clicking on the banner Canal CNE TV of the official site www.cne.gob.ve for anyone, anywhere to see.”
It appears that in compliance with the constitutional mandate, the CNE has created a unique legally bound and technologically sound electoral system, backed by the most comprehensive system of guarantees. This makes elections in Venezuela a safe, transparent and reliable expression of the sovereign will of the people and a full demonstration of a vibrant, participatory and protagonist democracy.
In concluding, the Venezuelan Consul stated, “democracy is taken very seriously and is intensely lived in Venezuela. For Venezuelans, to live in a democracy is to debate, participate and be full protagonists in the construction of their destiny. In Venezuela, the right to elect or be elected is conceived as an essential human right and the State strives to guarantee and secure that right by all means available. Transparency is at the heart of the electoral system for the May 20 elections in Venezuela”
(The above article is from the May16-31, 2018, issue of People's Voice, Canada's leading socialist newspaper. Articles can be reprinted free if the source is credited. Subscription rates in Canada: $30/year, or $15 low income rate; for U.S. readers - $45 US per year; other overseas readers - $45 US or $50 CDN per year. Send to People's Voice, c/o PV Business Manager, 706 Clark Drive, Vancouver, BC, V5L 3J1.)